date: Tue, 4 Jul 2000 10:24:01 +0700
from: "Sukachev Forest Institute" <instituteatXYZxyzest.akadem.ru>
subject: from Prof.Vaganov
to: "Briffa Keith" <K.BriffaatXYZxyz.ac.uk>
Draft of paper : Briffa K.R. et al. <Tree-ring width and density data around the
Hemisphere: part 1, local and regional climate signal>
I have no significant remarks over this rich of statistical analysis and complicated
paper. Only one
short note to page 7-8 where in first paragraph telling about weaker TRW climatic signal.
some earlier publications (for example, Hughes et al, 1999) where the highest correlation
between TRW and temperature is shown. The weakness, probably, related to heterogeneity of
(northern timberline and more southern) for large sectors you used and shifting the highest
earlier summer (spring) month towards to south. TRW is highly correlated (R=0,97-99) to
production, and in high latitudes the most of tracheids are produced by cambial zone in
first part of a
season, so mainly response to the starting date of beginning of a season (Vaganov,
Towards to the south, the starting dates are shifting to early date - it is obvious.
Draft of paper: Briffa et al. <Low-frequency temperature variations from a northern
network> (sorry, too many formal statistics for me).
Only some minor notes could be made.
1. Third paragraph in part 2 (page 5). Concerning Fig.3. - what is the differences between
dashed smoothed lines in individual curves (one is age, another is?). Maybe indicate it in
in figure captions.
2. Last paragraph in part 3. You may mentioned the similar results about warm 15-th and
17-th centuries which are shown in temperature reconstruction based on supra-long Taymir
chronology (Naurzbaev, Vaganov, 2000).
3. Last paragraph in part 4. The main similar cycles were revealed in analysis of Taymir
There are some relevant references (only ours):
1. Vaganov E.A., Shiyatov S.G., Mazepa V.S. Dendroclimatic Study in Ural-Siberian
Novosibirsk, Nauka, 1996, - 246 pp. (in Russ.).
Annual maps of June-July temperature anomalies over Siberian Subarctic were
based on 61 local tree-ring chronologies. There is an increasing of frequency of warm
summers for the
whole Siberian Subarctic in 20-th century.
2. Vaganov E.A., Shiyatov S.G., Hantemirov R.M., Naurzbaev M.M. Summer temperature
in high latitudes of Northern Hemisphere during last 1,5 millennia: a comparison analysis
and ice core data. Doklady AN, 1998, 338(5): 681-684 (in Russ. and Engl.).
Coincidence of long-term summer temperature changes in different regions of
during last 1,5 thousand years is shown. These changes agree well with Greenland's ice core
3. Vaganov E.A., Hughes M.K. Tree rings and global carbon cycle. Problems of Ecological
Monitoring and Ecosystem Modelling, 2000, 17: 36-48 (in Engl.).
A review of application of various tree-ring data (width, density, fire scars,
isotopic ratio etc.) to
evaluate of certain parameters of carbon cycle in forest ecosystems.
4. Naurzbaev M.M., Vaganov E.A. Variations of early summer and annual temperature in the
Taymir and Putoran over last two millennia inferred from tree-rings. J.Geophy.Res., 2000,
7317-7327 (in Engl.).
Reconstructed temperature variations agree well with other indirect proxy data and
warmth of Medieval Warm Period is closely to warmth in last century. Some cyclic components
significantly exist in temperature variations: double secular (around 180 years), secular
and intrasecular (44, 28, 11 and 6,7-6,9 years). Long coolest periods were in the end of 13
in 16-17 centuries.
5. Vaganov E.A., Briffa K.R., Naurzbaev M.M., Schweingruber F.H., Shiyatov S.G., Shishov
Long-term temperature changes in Arctic region. Doklady AN, 2000, (accepted) (in Russ. and
Similarity of long-term summer temperature changes in high latitudes of Northern
Asia over last 600 years, and significant correlation of its variations to volcanic sulfur
(negative) and solar irradiation (positive). Some disagreement between two large sector of
region revealed for cool period in 19-th century: in Asian sector cool period occur earlier
than in North
America and Greenland.
6. Vaganov E.A., Shashkin A.V. Tree-ring Growth and Structure in Conifers. Novosibirsk,
2000, - 238 pp. (will be published in September) (in Russ.).